SC slams CBI for 'scandalous allegations' against all Bengal courts
The Supreme Court on Friday criticized the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) for making "scandalous allegations" against all courts in West Bengal. The remarks came as the CBI sought a transfer of post-poll violence cases out of the state. Following strong criticism from Justices Abhay S Oka and Pankaj Mithal, Additional Solicitor General of India (ASG) SV Raju withdrew the transfer petition.
Supreme Court questions CBI's allegations against Bengal courts
The bench, led by Justice Oka, questioned the CBI's allegations of a "hostile environment" and illegal bail grants in all West Bengal courts. "Suppose we transfer matters then we are certifying that there is hostile atmosphere over all the courts in the state and courts are not functioning," Justice Oka told ASG. "It is unfortunate that central agencies like the CBI have cast such aspersions on the judiciary in this manner," the bench said.
CBI's transfer petition withdrawn following criticism
The CBI had filed a transfer petition in December 2023, seeking to move over 45 cases out of West Bengal due to alleged witness intimidation and threats to justice. The agency claimed that victims displaced by violence were being prevented from returning home by the ruling All India Trinamool Congress (TMC), and many witnesses were facing serious threats. Following the Supreme Court's criticism, ASG Raju admitted to some "loose drafting" in the petition and agreed to amend it.
CBI clarifies intent behind 'hostile environment' reference
ASG Raju clarified that the agency had no intention of casting aspersions on the judicial system. He explained that the mention of a "hostile environment" referred to threats and intimidation faced by victims and witnesses, rather than any bias within the judiciary. However, Justice Oka maintained that such language could warrant a contempt notice against the officer who filed the affidavit. "We make it clear that all objections to the proposed transfer are expressly kept open," the bench added.
